KOENCLASSYS.COM
Contents
Treatment Guide

Which Lifting Treatment Is Most Effective? How Results Are Measured and What They Depend On

Key Takeaways

  • A 2023 evidence review in Facial Plastic Surgery describes clinical practice guidelines for non-surgical facial rejuvenation as scarce.
  • Cleveland Clinic describes a non-surgical facelift as typically a combination of minimally invasive and non-surgical techniques and says non-surgical facelifts can take many forms.
  • In Contini and colleagues' 2023 review of microfocused ultrasound studies, three studies that measured laxity severity found that improvement declined as baseline skin laxity increased, and two studies concluded that a lower body mass index had a positive influence on outcomes.
  • Studies measure a non-surgical lift on photographs, on improvement scales, and with patient questionnaires such as the FACE-Q.
  • A 2025 systematic review of FACE-Q studies found that differences between studies (heterogeneity) limit comparison of facial cosmetic treatments through conventional meta-analyses.

Focused ultrasound is one of several non-surgical treatments for loose facial skin. Each study of non-surgical lifting reports results for the patients it enrolled, measured with the photographs, rating scales, or questionnaires that study used.

A 2023 evidence review in Facial Plastic Surgery found few clinical practice guidelines for non-surgical facial rejuvenation and significant variability in treatment protocols and outcome measures for several methods. A 2025 systematic review found that differences between studies limit comparison of facial cosmetic treatments.

The state of the evidence for non-surgical lifting

Neither the 2023 evidence review in Facial Plastic Surgery nor the 2025 systematic review of FACE-Q studies ranks non-surgical lifting treatments by effectiveness, and a comparison of lifting treatments depends on what change is being treated, in whom, and how the result is measured.

For non-surgical facial rejuvenation, the Facial Plastic Surgery review states that there remains a paucity of clinical practice guidelines and evidence-based recommendations, and it reports significant variability in treatment protocols and outcome measures for several methods, including energy-based facial rejuvenation (Evidence-Based Medicine for Nonsurgical Facial Rejuvenation).

The many forms of a non-surgical facelift

Cleveland Clinic does not name a single best non-surgical facelift; it describes a non-surgical facelift as typically a combination of minimally invasive and non-surgical techniques, used for concerns that range from sagging skin and loose jowls to sunken cheeks and wrinkles (Nonsurgical Facelift: What It Is, Options & Benefits).

Energy-based skin tightening is one approach to loose skin. The American Society for Dermatologic Surgery (ASDS) describes non-invasive skin tightening devices as non-surgical devices intended to stimulate collagen production deep in the skin, and it says the devices, over time, "work to shrink tissue, which has lost its tone and elasticity." According to the same page, most of these devices heat the skin tissue with laser, radiofrequency, or ultrasound energy, alone or in combination (Non-invasive Skin Tightening Treatments).

Three-quarter view of an older woman's cheek, mouth and jaw with fine wrinkles and loose skin, not a treatment result

Factors that change how well a non-surgical lift works

In Contini and colleagues' 2023 review of microfocused ultrasound studies, the degree of skin laxity and body mass index were the patient factors linked to how much improvement was reported. Microfocused ultrasound is a focused ultrasound technique, and the review concluded that the treatment is effective in tightening mildly to moderately lax facial skin in women. Several of the included studies excluded people with excessive skin laxity, and three studies that measured laxity severity found that improvement declined as baseline laxity increased. The studies often excluded people with excess fat under the skin or a high body mass index, and two studies concluded that a lower body mass index had a positive influence on outcomes. In these studies, the amount of improvement was found to vary between individuals with different degrees of laxity and body mass index (A Systematic Review of the Efficacy of Microfocused Ultrasound for Facial Skin Tightening).

The studies that excluded people with excessive laxity, excess fat under the skin, or a high body mass index report no results for those people. Most of the patients in the studies included in the Contini review were adult women, and the authors note that it is not known whether the results can be reproduced in men. Why skin loses firmness is the subject of What Causes Skin Laxity, and What Actually Improves It.

Outcome measures in non-surgical lifting studies

Studies of non-surgical lifting measure results in different ways, from changes measured on photographs to improvement scales scored by investigators or patients and questionnaires such as the FACE-Q, so a result from one study is hard to compare directly with a result from another. The Contini review also notes that a lift measured in a study is not necessarily visible to the eye and does not necessarily look more pleasing.

Limits on comparing non-surgical lifting treatments

A 2025 systematic review of FACE-Q studies found significant heterogeneity among studies of facial cosmetic treatments and says this limits comparison of the treatments through conventional meta-analyses. The review pooled studies that measured results with the FACE-Q and considers the heterogeneity likely due to differing patient characteristics, procedural techniques, and time horizons for the outcomes. It says its pooled estimates should be interpreted with caution (Measuring the Impact of Surgical and Non-surgical Facial Cosmetic Interventions Using FACE-Q Aesthetic Module Scales: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis).

Even studies of the same treatment type differ in how the treatment was delivered. The microfocused ultrasound studies in the Contini review used various device settings, treatment protocols, and energies, and each study's result was obtained with that study's own devices, settings, and patients.

In microfocused ultrasound, delivery also includes the layout of the ultrasound pulses, or shots, which are placed along treatment lines that run parallel to one another. The Contini review notes that the direction of these lines can be changed, for example to horizontal, vertical, or criss-cross. The direction is a separate setting from the transducer's frequency, which determines how deeply the ultrasound penetrates, so line layout counts as a separate setting when focused ultrasound treatments are compared.

Sources

  1. Hari-Raj A, Spataro EA. Evidence-Based Medicine for Nonsurgical Facial Rejuvenation. Facial Plastic Surgery. 2023;39(3):230-236. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36584886/ ↗
  2. Cleveland Clinic. Nonsurgical Facelift: What It Is, Options & Benefits. Last updated 08/18/2022. https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/treatments/24018-non-surgical-facelift ↗
  3. American Society for Dermatologic Surgery. Non-invasive Skin Tightening Treatments. https://www.asds.net/skin-experts/skin-treatments/non-invasive-skin-tightening-treatments ↗
  4. Contini M, Hollander MHJ, Vissink A, Schepers RH, Jansma J, Schortinghuis J. A Systematic Review of the Efficacy of Microfocused Ultrasound for Facial Skin Tightening. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2023;20(2):1522. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9861614/ ↗
  5. Gallo L, Kim P, Churchill IF, et al. Measuring the Impact of Surgical and Non-surgical Facial Cosmetic Interventions Using FACE-Q Aesthetic Module Scales: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Plastic Surgery. 2025;33(3):403-418. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11562317/ ↗

Frequently asked questions

Which lifting treatment is most effective?

Microfocused ultrasound, a focused ultrasound technique, is one of the non-surgical options, none of which is ranked by effectiveness in the 2023 evidence review in Facial Plastic Surgery or in the 2025 systematic review of FACE-Q studies. In this treatment, ultrasound is focused below the skin so that small points of tissue at chosen depths are heated while the skin's surface is not broken. The direction of the treatment lines, along which the heated points are placed, also differs between treatments, which gives one more way to tell focused ultrasound options apart. The Facial Plastic Surgery review found few clinical practice guidelines and significant variability in treatment protocols and outcome measures for several methods, and the FACE-Q review found that differences between studies limit comparison of facial cosmetic treatments. Contini and colleagues' 2023 review of microfocused ultrasound studies found improvement linked to the degree of skin laxity and to body mass index.

Which non-surgical facelift gives the best results?

Cleveland Clinic lists dermal fillers, chemical peels, laser skin resurfacing, and microneedling among non-surgical facelift options and does not rank them by results. It describes a non-surgical facelift as typically a combination of minimally invasive and non-surgical techniques used for different concerns. Each published study of these options reports results only for the patients it enrolled and the products, devices, and settings it used.

Which non-surgical facelifts are effective?

Both injectable and energy-based non-surgical treatments have been studied. For microfocused ultrasound, a focused ultrasound technique, Contini and colleagues' 2023 systematic review concluded that the treatment is effective in tightening mildly to moderately lax facial skin in women, and most patients in the studies it included were adult women. A 2023 evidence review in Facial Plastic Surgery found that the amount of high-level research differs between non-surgical methods.

Does the amount of sagging change how well a non-surgical lift works?

In microfocused ultrasound studies, yes. In Contini and colleagues' 2023 systematic review, three studies that measured the severity of skin laxity (loose or sagging skin) found less improvement as baseline laxity increased. Several studies in that review excluded people with excessive laxity, and two studies concluded that a lower body mass index had a positive influence on outcomes.

How do studies measure whether a lift worked?

Studies compare photographs taken at baseline and at follow-up, and investigators or patients score the change on improvement scales. The FACE-Q Aesthetic module, a patient questionnaire, records satisfaction with facial appearance, health-related quality of life, and adverse effects of treatment.

This content is for general information only and does not guarantee the results of any treatment. Any treatment decision should be made in consultation with a qualified medical professional.